Summary: This little tale takes place shortly after the White Council
met in TA 2851 (We are using 'shortly' in the elven perception of such
a word). Let's pretend that Legolas and Bilbo were born the same year,
2890, and that no elf has been inside the Wood Elves' Realm since
before the Last Alliance, over two thousand years ago. Having lost so
many elves, the silvan folk have reverted to a more instinctual means
of survival and their Sindar 'guests' go along, having no where else to
go that did not include rubbing shoulders with those sneaky Noldor.
Features 'good Ada Thranduil', perhaps in a somewhat surprising
cultural situation.
Beta'd
by Sarah AK, remaining errors are mine alone.
Italics indicate thoughts.
I. Rain, Rain Go Away
Normally he quite liked rain. There was something positively soothing
about the incessant spattering of liquid on leaves, an absolute charm
invoked by chattering droplets dancing over stone, a significant
soporific effect rendered by the sound of gently falling water. Like a
thousand thousand polished pearls plinking upon the tiled roof above
his rooms, the music of rain always put him to sleep with sweetness and
dreams of pleasant days.
Yes, really he loved stormy weather. The slicing glare of lightening
bolts diving from the clouds to blast the land and scorch the grass,
the raucous din of thunder shaking air and earth alike, the piercing
whine of a gale bowing the tops of the tallest trees as if they were
mere saplings. All of it was a magnificent show and he never tired of
enjoying such entertainment. Rainstorms somehow made fire feel warmer,
candlelight more radiant, his favourite chair a cosy refuge. Often such
a meteorological turn would find him ensconced within his study, well
worn book held before him as a shield against the troubles of the
times, relishing the sensation of being entirely safe and beyond reach
of any malicious thing upon Arda.
On this particular afternoon, however, he was unable to summon up even
the most remotely appreciative notion of the value of rain. Not 'the
crops need it' or 'fall rains spare summer's drought' or even 'it is
good for the Dorwinion' could find a comfortable place in his
consideration of the wet weather this day. No, today he found that he
despised the unending torrent pouring in heavy sheets of steely grey
from a sky so burdened with bursting clouds it looked ready to collapse
unto the very ground. It was as if the ocean was now lifted up,
suspended in the air and filtering through a fine sieve, while the
gross weight of the water threatened to fracture whatever bonds of
black magic held it aloft and send the whole of the Great Sea plunging
upon his head at any moment.
Perhaps his recently acquired dislike for pluvial phenomena was because
he was out-of-doors slogging through it. It was likely that the
belligerent glare with which he occasionally favoured the heavens was
due to the fact that said phenomenon had been ongoing for five days and
four nights. Mayhap his sudden distaste for the sound of pattering
droplets had to do with the unbearable squelchy noise these created
when landing determinedly on the soaked tresses of his cold, nay,
definitely more like frigidly numb, head. He was saturated right
through all the layers of clothing covering his body and Ulmo's icy
fingers ran over him, touching and exploring every inch of skin in a
most unpleasant and indecent manner.
Lest any mistake be made at this point regarding the intelligence of
this poor sopping traveller, such as to wonder why the wretch had not
the foresight to carry along a coat as protection against the changes
of weather inherent to any journey of more than moderate distance, rest
assured our friend was suitably garbed and provisioned for inclemency.
The finely made cloak about his shoulders had sufficed well enough the
first day of the deluge and even provided passable coverage on the
second. By the third dawn, a wan and decidedly dreary lead-coloured one
at that, the hood of the cape had absorbed as much as the fibres of the
fabric could hold and drooped over his face, flapping with an
irritating squish against his nose and forehead with every step his
equally miserable and water-logged steed took. He had flung the cowl
back with an exasperated and excessively energetic sweep of his arm.
That was on the third day. By sunset of the fifth, heralded by an
almost immediate loss of all ability to see through the downpour and
thus the need to halt, Erestor was out of patience.
For this worthy elf, valiant warrior and compatriot of such legends as
Gil-Galad and Celebrimbror, kinsman to Elrond Lord of Imladris, was
indeed the erstwhile traveller struggling through the onslaught. With
him rode two other elves from Rivendell; warriors to be his protection
should trouble strike. These two watched placidly as their noble leader
vented his frustration, sharing a sly look that expressed eloquently
the enjoyment their unflappable superior's abrupt loss of composure
granted. Yes, this would make a fine tale for the Hall of Fire.
Much waste of bodily warmth was given off to the transparent and
unrelenting rain in the form of vile and voluble expletives shouted in
five different languages (Quenya, Sindarin, Old Nandorin, Westron, and
High Dwarvish), punctuated by gestures of arms, hands and fingers,
expressive in their own rights, towards the crowded skies, the muddy,
oozing earth beneath the horse's slipping hooves, and the unending
ranks of dull brown trees to either side of the well-worn track.
Erestor cursed the shortness of the day, the short-sightedness of the
dwarves who built a highway with no means of securing shelter along its
entirety, and the short-of-wit Wood Elves for being so xenophobic as to
make this tribulation necessary. For the travellers could do nothing
other than stop, just where they were upon the road, and wait until
some semblance of illumination returned, unable to light a fire or rig
up shelter under the trees.
The trio had little in the way of choices: (1) get down and sit in the
slimy mire, (2) clamber up into the branches, or (3) remain on the
animals' backs, hunched over in weary misery until morning. The first
option was never even considered. It was quite abominable enough to be
this completely cold and wet without the added experience of gritty mud
seeping up through one's leggings and into every crevice, crack, and
crease available upon one's rear end. The second idea, while initially
appearing to hold merit, turned out to be worse.
Climbing trees was not a skill taught to Noldorin warriors and noble
statesmen. Assuming it was something any fit and able elf could do,
rather than a skill requiring frequent practice, had proved unwise, for
as coated with liquid as the bark was the limbs simply would not stay
within hands' clasp and boots' purchase. The result was a thoroughly
humiliating tumble down into the soup, thus initiating precisely the
conditions they had sought to avoid by not reposing on the ground.
So there they were, five days out of Lorien, three of the most
uncomfortably drippy and forlorn elves ever to grace the Old Dwarven
Road with their splendourous, if somewhat limp and damp, magnificence.
In addition to Erestor, aptly considered a noble and wily statesman,
though no novice to combat and quite capable with a sword was he, were
his companions Toloth (Eight) and Cugu (Dove).
"Valar!" swore Cugu and spat, though what insult his saliva might
inflict upon the verily flowing ground was unclear.
"Do not start," warned Toloth. He fingers splashed about in his pockets
and retrieved a small tightly wrapped packet. "Here," he said, tossing
the item to his comrade. But the streaming water made the air more
resistant to such attempts to float things upon it and the little
bundle fell to the path with a splat that had a distinct quality of
mockery to its emanating vibrations.
"That tears it!" Cugu fumed and slipped from his horse into the ankle
deep slurry of ruddy dirt and grabbed up the package fiercely.
"Hear, now, I did not mean to drop it!"
"Aye, nothing but mush, as I suspected!" he seethed after inspecting
the contents, which had only seconds ago been a wholesome wafer of
lembas, and violently cast the remnants back to the sucking greed of
the flowing land. A rather insolent snicker met his hearing and he spun
on his heel to glare hard at the elven noble.
"What is the matter with you?" demanded Erestor sternly and glowered
back with all the power of a First-age hero.
"I just do not think our situation merits mirth," countered Cugu as he
remounted his stallion.
"Nor do I; it was not me," declared Erestor coldly. "Mind your tongue."
"But it has been five days of it!" mourned Cugu, shooting a suspicious
glance at Toloth.
"We have been right beside you; it is not news to us!" countered Toloth
irritably.
"Well why does it never cease?" the rant continued. "This is unnatural,
that is certain! I tell you we are all turned around and going the
wrong way! We should go back!"
"How can we be heading in the wrong direction when the road only goes
west by east, and we entered upon the eastern side?" reasoned Toloth.
"Yes, calm yourself, Cugu!" ordered Erestor, grimacing even as he spoke
the ridiculous name. "It is not uncommon to have rain go on for days.
It once did so for ten days straight in Eregion. We will not retreat."
Cugu scowled but remained quiet.
It was unseemly, undignified, and absolutely absurd for a veteran
warrior of the Last Alliance of Elves and Men to answer to such a
humble designation, in Erestor's opinion. Of course it was not the
edhel's true name. He was really Caladchae (Distant Light) and that was
more appropriate for a Noldorin elf since it referred to the knowledge
and wisdom of Valinor from whence they emigrated.
Oh, all right, we
were thrown out, but that was a long time ago. No one ever called
him that and Cugu did not appear to mind. In fact, Erestor had
attempted to retrain him to the more prestigious moniker but the
warrior never realised he was being spoken to when it was used.
His colleague's name was perhaps worse. Why on Arda would anyone refer
to one's self as a cardinal number? Of course he had a proper Noldorin
appellation, Cuilvedui (Last Life), that referenced his Naneth's final
creative enterprise before leaving for the Undying Lands. For some time
Erestor had believed the inu had borne eight offspring, a truly
remarkable achievement, but Toloth himself had denied this notion.
Whenever Erestor used the warrior's real name, he politely corrected
his superior, asking that his chosen designation be substituted. Not
wishing to appear either rude or nosy, for he was definitely not the
former and only moderately the latter, Erestor had acquiesced without
further inquiry.
He had known them for Ages, not that well of course, owing to their
differences in station and class. This journey had thrown them together
on a more or less continual basis, however, and Erestor had learned the
two were lovers; had been for centuries. He further discovered that
each had bestowed upon the other, sometime during the mid- to late
Second Age, those darling little pet-names. Exactly what circumstances,
traits, or events had inspired the selection of these particular words
as endearments, Erestor really, truly did not wish to find out.
As far as the meaning of his own name, the noble elf kept that a most
carefully guarded secret and not even his best friend, Glorfindel, knew
who had bestowed it, when, or what it could possibly mean. Erestor was
aware that it was a common source of practical joking on unsuspecting
visitors to Imladris. The household cook gave odds on how long it would
take the ignorant guest to become completely baffled and give up the
presented challenge, that being something along the lines of 'if you
can get Erestor to explain where he got his name, there is a bottle of
fine Dorwinion awaiting you'. Few had enough sense to forego the bet
and frequently Erestor himself had won the resultant booty.
"How much further is it likely to be?" asked Toloth.
"Now who is starting!" railed Cugu and flung a handful of watery silt
into his lover's face.
"Oi! I told you I did not drop it on purpose!"
"As I have already mentioned at least twice a day over the course of
the trip, I am not sure," snapped Erestor and turned a fractious
grimace upon Toloth having registered a very rude giggly snort.
"What? I was only wondering!" whined Toloth, then rounded on Cugu with
a snarl as he reached over and tugged his mate's sopping hood down over
his face. "Laugh at me, will you?" he hissed, for he had noticed a smug
guffaw from that general direction.
"Fie!" shouted Cugu, struggling to unwrap the clinging fabric, angered
for he could now detect both his comrades scoffing at him. Just as he
pulled it off and bared his tress-plastered head, a small, hard rounded
object bounced with a sharp ping right from the crown of it and landed
with a little plop into the murky puddles. More sniggers ensued, and
all three Noldor realised they were the butt
butts? of some
rather annoying pranksters' foolery. They exchanged wary glances and
shifted their examination upwards. In the dark, drenched air nothing
could be seen but the shifting shadows of branches swaying in the wind.
"Show yourselves!" demanded Erestor. "We mean you no harm! We are
visitors from the west, here to meet your King and learn of your people
and your lands."
"Go home!" a sudden shrill voice piped out from directly above the
statesman's head, followed by a rain of a new sort as the travellers
were pelted with a barrage of acorns and hazel nuts while their
assailants laughed gleefully.
"Ai!"
"Eru's arse!"
"Bugger a Balrog!"
These exclamations only initiated a second volley of mast and louder
peals of hilarity that seemed to be coming from several directions at
once, accompanied by slurs upon Noldor ancestry and morals. The attack
did not last long, however, and soon the three elves heard the giggling
diminishing to the north as if their hidden tormentors were retreating
into the dense woods, which of course they were.
"Wood Elves!' sneered Cugu and spat again. "Ignorant, uncouth, tree
crawlers!"
"I cannot believe old Gandalf thinks there is any value in trying to
make allies of these folk. It did not work the last time, you know,"
added Toloth.
If these reactions seem a bit extreme that is owing to the losses both
these warriors endured during the Last Alliance, when the woodland
elves were blamed for causing a rather futile raid upon the Black Gates
that cost hundreds of immortal lives. That, and the rain, of course.
"Aye, I do realise they are a primitive lot," agreed Erestor, "but the
White Council has made its decision. It is not up to us to make it
work, but merely to initiate contact once more with these elusive
forest dwellers."
Erestor was supposed to remain aloof from such prejudicial
interpretations, at least in public, yet he was not in a very
conciliatory mood after five days travel under such adverse conditions.
The noble Noldo was not blind to Gandalf's imperative, yet was anything
but convinced of the effectiveness of their mission, even if he could
succeed and re-open Thranduil's Northern Kingdom to the rest of
elvendom and the west.
To be entirely fair, it was not so much Gandalf who had suggested the
idea as Celeborn, and he had somehow or other coerced Galadriel into
backing him, and that of course brought Gandalf on board. Cirdan always
sided with Gandalf. Saruman concurred sagely, finding it advisable to
re-establish ties between the remaining enclaves of the First-born, and
Radagast never disagreed publicly with his superior. That left Elrond
standing there
well sitting there with arms crossed and a foul
expression etched into his sullen features, the only hold out.
The situation that had called them together was certainly grave.
Gandalf had discovered unequivocally that it was indeed Sauron who was
stirring up Dol Guldur again and breeding Orcs by the thousands. The
Maia had urged an offensive attack upon the fortress to drive the vile
disciple of Melkor away once more, but in this the White Wizard had
overruled him. No one argued against Saruman's decision, for none
believed enough elven forces could be brought together to defeat what
appeared to be an ever increasing supply of evil demons, goblins, and
men poised to serve Sauron.
Thus the decision to enlist the aid of the Wood Elves, as they had much
to bear with the Evil One right in their very midst. Since the Last
Alliance, they had retreated to the northernmost reaches of the great
forest and rumours abounded as to the increasingly fey and feral nature
of these moriquendi. With Oropher dead, the Sindar remnant and the
silvan tribes were headed by Thranduil, who had apparently gone to
ground, dwelling in caves to evade capture and persecution in Dol
Guldur.
The Council had met in 2851 and forty-four years later, in 2895; Elrond
had finally given in. The Wise all met in Lorien once more to work out
the details, except for Saruman who claimed to be searching for
Radagast, last seen along the River Gladden.
The Lord of Imladris was the most likely candidate for the mission;
however, he flatly refused to be the emissary. He had some grudge or
other against Thranduil and would not bow to him, saying the Sinda was
really not any sort of royalty. Gandalf nominated Celeborn, who had to
decline because of his marriage to Galadriel, for whom Thranduil had
some unreasonable dread associated with the kinslaying at Alqualonde.
Alright,
perhaps not completely unreasonable, but it was Ages ago and nothing
was ever proved against her anyway. Then Elrond suggested for
Gandalf to do it, but he said it was a matter for elves and proposed
Glorfindel. Everyone was happy with that except Glorfindel, who had a
nasty habit of attracting bad luck and preferred to remain as far from
Sauron as possible.
"No," he said simply and firmly. "Send Erestor, he never gets to do
anything even remotely heroic and I am sure feels slighted by such
neglect of his diverse skills in both diplomacy and swordsmanship, not
to mention savoir faire and finesse. Besides, Thranduil has no reason,
as yet, to ban him from the forest."
Well that last remark raised a few eyebrows and many wondered exactly
what Glorfindel had been up to for the Wood Elves' King to flat out
forbid him to enter the realm, but the Balrog Slayer promptly sealed
his lips and refused to elaborate.
There had been no one left upon which Erestor could foist the duty,
however, for Galdor was in the Havens visiting with Cirdan. Elladan and
Elrohir volunteered, but their father denied their request with no
explanation other than to say "Caradhras", after which the twins grew
morose and silent and eventually rode out to kill Orcs. And thus
Erestor, Cugu, and Toloth departed from the comfort and security of
fair Lothlorien
Where it is nearly always sunny and warm, making
rain and thunderstorms seem a delightful diversion. to seek out
the Kingdom of the Wood Elves and re-initiate diplomatic relations with
Eru's less wise and more ferocious children.
As the unending torrential rain drilled upon his pate throughout the
eternity of the fifth dreary, deluged night, Erestor decided that when
he returned to Imladris he was going to have to find an appropriate
means of expressing his gratitude to Glorfindel for the glowing
recommendation which had secured his participation in such an
illustrious undertaking.
TBC